I’ll let you into a little secret. Although the idea of ‘school streets’ seems radical, the legislation allowing us to deliver them has been around for decades.
School streets are essentially just ‘pedestrian and cycle zones’ which use traffic orders and some of the tools of filtered permeability to create quieter or motor traffic-free streets around schools. As with any scheme, local context is important in tailoring the design for the situation. The basic traffic sign to be aware of is 618.3C of the Traffic Signs Regulations & General Directions 2016 (TSRGD16) and this is used at the entry points to the ‘school street’;
For a school street, we’re not going to need to worry about all of the permutations, but I think the following will be our considerations;
- The ‘pedestrian and cycle zone’ wording and the red circle with the motor car and motorcycle is a basic requirement. It means that the way ahead is only for people walking and cycling; and we want the latter because we want kids cycling to school.
- Next we have the times of operation. This is going to be Monday to Friday for the main part and the times are going to straddle the start and end of the school day. I’ll come back to this in a minute.
- Exceptions can include blue badge holders, loading, permit holders, buses and taxis. Blue badge holders might be exempted, especially is there are pupils being driven to school or a member of school staff needing assistance, although it may be that the member of staff arrives before the restriction starts. We don’t want loading or taxi access at all in my view, although bus access might be needed.
- The “at any time” plate at the bottom essentially explains that beyond the entry point, there is no parking or waiting to take place – in essence it’s a signed version of a double yellow line. This can be varied to a part time control and in all cases, repeater signs are needed. If there is a general problem with parking, then this can be a useful (and tidy) addition.
- Of course, as this operates on a zonal basis, we can include as many streets as we like.
Unless the parking controls introduced on the entry sign are being used, it’s a kind of pointless sign because if one is not allowed to drive in during the restriction times, then one won’t see the sign. If one drives into the zone when it’s not operational, then it’s academic. However, it might just help reinforce the zonal approach when people notice is and so I’ll go with it and as pointed out by @ShowMeASignBryn;
“the Zone Ends sign is important to warn people inside the Zone that they are passing the end of the restricted area and should be aware of “normal” road conditions past the sign especially if the street design is identical.”
In terms of keeping people out during the restriction time, there are two main options;
- Camera enforcement. Using automatic number plate recognition (ANPR), those driving into the zone will be detected and a fine issued by the traffic authority. Fixed cameras can cost £15k-20k each to procure and install and they need power, communications and a ‘back office’ to process the fine. CCTV cars are the other way to deal with the enforcement and so they could be deployed randomly as part of general tasking.
- Removable/ foldable bollards or gates can be used to physically prevent motor traffic accessing the zone. This requires somebody to physically deal with the bollards and gates. If the zone has a morning and afternoon restriction, then this means the closure is attended to four times.
With the physical approach, the easiest way to manage this would be by putting a formal agreement in place with the school, so they can deal with the process. Because we are also probably only going to run such a scheme during term time, it would also make sense to enlist the school’s help to change the signs at the start and end of term as well. If we don’t do this, then the restriction would apply during the school holidays. This might actually be fine, but if residents or business are affected, then we may want to take them into account during holidays.
The easiest way to manage the signs would be to use a folding sign which can be locked open or closed as required and this could again, be managed by the school by agreement. There are also variable signs that have rotating prisms which do the same job, but it’s something else to maintain. Here’s an example of a folding sign from a scheme in Hackney;
You can see that the top half of the sign folds down to cover the bottom half and there are toggle locks to hold it in place. In this example, the restriction applies for 45 minutes in the morning and the afternoon and people with the correct permit are exempt (this could be residents or businesses). In fact, Hackney has quite a nice scheme explainer and details on it’s website as does Edinburgh.
How such a scheme is established is up to you. A permanent scheme requires the usual public consultation, traffic order and decision-making process. Alternatively, an experimental traffic order could be used which allows a live scheme to be part of the consultation process. Either way, it is likely to need a decent level of public engagement because in essence, we are telling people they cannot drive somewhere.
A permit system perhaps reduces the pain for residents and if their street is usually blocked at school times, they may welcome it. Care needs to be taken that the problems in the streets by the school don’t just get pushed a bit further out with unintended results being the issue. However, given that it only takes a few parents to increase the risk exposure to many children, then it’s a welcome use of one of our traffic management tools.
If we make driving kids to school harder, some who are making the short trips will give up and walk (or cycle). I acknowledge that some people drop their kids off as part of their journey to work or elsewhere, but that doesn’t give them licence to park next to the school or put everyone else at risk. They’ll have to change.